Is the Eucharist Cannibalism?
By William Braswell
-
Is the Eucharist Cannibalism?
Early Church Christians were labeled as cannibals by Roman pagans who misunderstood the belief in the presence of the Eucharist (The Lord's Supper) as literal consumption of God. This misinterpretation highlights the ancient roots of the Christian doctrine of the Eucharist, where Jesus' words at the Last Supper are taken literal. It is categorically not an act of cannibalism. This distinction rests upon a proper understanding of the nature of Christ’s offering, the character of His glorified humanity, the sacramental mode of His presence, and the teleological purpose of communion.
First, the Eucharist is not the involuntary consumption of a human being, as in cannibalism, but the free and voluntary self-offering of the incarnate Son of God. As Christ declares in John 10:17–18, “No one takes my life from me, but I lay it down of my own accord.” The Church does not take or kill Christ in the Eucharist; rather, she receives the gift of His life, which He offers sacrificially for the salvation of the world. This self-offering is not re-enacted as a new death every time it is performed, but made present as a single, eternal sacrifice by the operation of the Holy Spirit. The liturgical tradition affirms this in the anaphora: “Thine own of Thine own we offer unto Thee, on behalf of all and for all.” Thus, the Eucharist is not the violent taking of a body, but the reception of divine life, freely given.
Second, the Body and Blood received in the Eucharist are not those of a mortal, corruptible human subject but of the risen and glorified Christ. The Church teaches that in the Eucharist, the faithful partake of the very Body that was crucified, raised, and glorified. St. John of Damascus articulates this with clarity: “If you inquire how this happens, it is enough for you to learn that it is through the Holy Spirit... the bread and wine are not mere figures of the body and blood of Christ...God forbid! but the deified body of the Lord itself.” Christ, having conquered death, is now incorruptible and alive forevermore (cf. Rev. 1:18), and it is in this mode (glorified and deified) that He is communicated to the faithful. Cannibalism involves the consumption of dead flesh and the destruction of the victim; by contrast, the Eucharist communicates the living Christ, whole and undivided, and brings life to those who receive Him.
Third, the mode of Christ’s presence in the Eucharist is sacramental, not carnal. The Church affirms the real presence of Christ, but this presence is mystical, real yet spiritual, not empirical or materialistic. The outward appearances or "accidents/subjects" of bread and wine remain, but their inner substance (οὐσία) becomes, through the invocation of the Holy Spirit, the very Body and Blood of Christ. This transformation transcends material analysis. St. Cyril of Jerusalem instructs: “Do not look upon the bread and wine as something ordinary… but know that they are the Body and Blood of Christ.” The Eucharist is not a literal chewing of muscle or a drinking of plasma, but a sacramental communion through which the faithful receive the total Christ, Body, Blood, soul, and divinity, under the forms of bread and wine. Cannibalism, by contrast, is carnal, empirical, and mutilative.
The end or telos of the Eucharist decisively differentiates it from cannibalism. Cannibalism serves the survival of the consumer by destroying the consumed. The Eucharist, however, is ordered toward union, transformation, and deification (θέωσις). As St. Augustine remarks: “I am the food of the mature: grow, and you shall eat Me. But you will not change Me into yourself, like food of your flesh; rather, you will be changed into Me.” The communicant is not the one who assimilates Christ, but rather is assimilated into Him. The Eucharist does not diminish Christ but glorifies the communicant. It is, in the words of St. Ignatius of Antioch, “the medicine of immortality, the antidote against death, and the food that makes us live forever in Jesus Christ.” The Church maintains that the Eucharist is not a physical or violent consumption of human flesh, but a sacramental participation in the glorified, life-giving Christ. Far from being cannibalistic, it is the supreme act of divine love, a mystery through which the faithful are united to Christ in His resurrected life and transformed into His likeness.
First, the Eucharist is not the involuntary consumption of a human being, as in cannibalism, but the free and voluntary self-offering of the incarnate Son of God. As Christ declares in John 10:17–18, “No one takes my life from me, but I lay it down of my own accord.” The Church does not take or kill Christ in the Eucharist; rather, she receives the gift of His life, which He offers sacrificially for the salvation of the world. This self-offering is not re-enacted as a new death every time it is performed, but made present as a single, eternal sacrifice by the operation of the Holy Spirit. The liturgical tradition affirms this in the anaphora: “Thine own of Thine own we offer unto Thee, on behalf of all and for all.” Thus, the Eucharist is not the violent taking of a body, but the reception of divine life, freely given.
Second, the Body and Blood received in the Eucharist are not those of a mortal, corruptible human subject but of the risen and glorified Christ. The Church teaches that in the Eucharist, the faithful partake of the very Body that was crucified, raised, and glorified. St. John of Damascus articulates this with clarity: “If you inquire how this happens, it is enough for you to learn that it is through the Holy Spirit... the bread and wine are not mere figures of the body and blood of Christ...God forbid! but the deified body of the Lord itself.” Christ, having conquered death, is now incorruptible and alive forevermore (cf. Rev. 1:18), and it is in this mode (glorified and deified) that He is communicated to the faithful. Cannibalism involves the consumption of dead flesh and the destruction of the victim; by contrast, the Eucharist communicates the living Christ, whole and undivided, and brings life to those who receive Him.
Third, the mode of Christ’s presence in the Eucharist is sacramental, not carnal. The Church affirms the real presence of Christ, but this presence is mystical, real yet spiritual, not empirical or materialistic. The outward appearances or "accidents/subjects" of bread and wine remain, but their inner substance (οὐσία) becomes, through the invocation of the Holy Spirit, the very Body and Blood of Christ. This transformation transcends material analysis. St. Cyril of Jerusalem instructs: “Do not look upon the bread and wine as something ordinary… but know that they are the Body and Blood of Christ.” The Eucharist is not a literal chewing of muscle or a drinking of plasma, but a sacramental communion through which the faithful receive the total Christ, Body, Blood, soul, and divinity, under the forms of bread and wine. Cannibalism, by contrast, is carnal, empirical, and mutilative.
The end or telos of the Eucharist decisively differentiates it from cannibalism. Cannibalism serves the survival of the consumer by destroying the consumed. The Eucharist, however, is ordered toward union, transformation, and deification (θέωσις). As St. Augustine remarks: “I am the food of the mature: grow, and you shall eat Me. But you will not change Me into yourself, like food of your flesh; rather, you will be changed into Me.” The communicant is not the one who assimilates Christ, but rather is assimilated into Him. The Eucharist does not diminish Christ but glorifies the communicant. It is, in the words of St. Ignatius of Antioch, “the medicine of immortality, the antidote against death, and the food that makes us live forever in Jesus Christ.” The Church maintains that the Eucharist is not a physical or violent consumption of human flesh, but a sacramental participation in the glorified, life-giving Christ. Far from being cannibalistic, it is the supreme act of divine love, a mystery through which the faithful are united to Christ in His resurrected life and transformed into His likeness.